Show and tell!
Here are the two Shetland Shawls, side by side. Smaller needle version is on the left; larger needle version on the right:
Closeup of small version (Shetland I)
And Shetland II:
Which do you like better? I like the look of the smaller one, and the airy gossamer feel of the bigger one. I keep changing my mind, though. They both make me really happy, and I hope the gift recipient likes hers!