I knit a sweater for DH in 2021.
It’s a lovely sweater, but I like it better on me than on him. I think it’s because this yarn (Berroco Vintage) is soft and drapey, and the sweaters that I like on him have more body to them.
I want to knit another sweater for him, and when I saw Paul Haesemeyer’s sweater in Knitty, I was smitten. Bonus: He’s having a KAL and it’s opening weekend right now!
The sweater is knit in bulky weight yarn, which should be relatively quick. The sample was knit in an alpaca blend, but I ordered Knit Picks Wool of the Andes Bulky in Mineral Heather, which should have more body, and be less warm.
I think I’ll make it with a relaxed fit, but not as oversized as Paul’s. DH is not a large person, and I don’t want him to look like the sweater is wearing him! I could knit it in the round up to the armholes instead of in pieces. Does it need the structure of the side seams? My favorite sweater that I knit for him was knit in the round to the armholes. I altered the drop shoulder construction to cut in at the armhole, and picked up the stitches at the shoulder and worked downward, instead of knitting the sleeve and then sewing it in. Hmmm.
On the other hand, knitting it flat would make it easier to swatch for gauge, and I could avoid the “keep knitting and figure it out” debacle that I just did gauge-wise on my recent Starfall sample. (Knitting in the round takes longer to figure out that your first instinct was a bad choice…) I don’t have to decide about the sleeves until later. And I could knit it with or without cables on the sleeves…
Anyway, I’m dreaming of how I want to modify it, and I haven’t even swatched yet. Stay tuned.
PDXKnitterati 
Your sweater is gorgeous. Paul’s sweater is beautiful. Can’t wait to see the progress and the finished sweater.
Lucky DH !! 🙂
Your husband’s sweater is gorgeous! Wondering how it would look in blue and orange! 😃
I admire your ability to re-imagine a pattern and the necessary skills to execute it.
That is a great-looking sweater! When I started knitting almost all the sweater patterns were knit flat and sewn together, so I kind of like to do that construction every once in a while, just for old times sake 🙂
I saw this same pattern also in Knitty and I was thinking about knitting this for myself? I really like the design, great cables. but then I was thinking , well, how would it look on the female body?
Will it look too boxy specially on shoulders, drooping too much ? Also started also thinking about alterations….
I don’t know. Any opinions ? I have a squarish body and I am not big busted person. I am tempted.